hzrd14912h agoI respectfully disagree but not because of the fingerprinting, even though its worse on nostr then google analytics. but because when apps push users to sign NIP-42 indiscriminately they are effectively pushing the user to give full control of their nsec over to the app, presuming the user clicks "approve all".
The best thing the user can do with these apps is select "approve all relay auth" but nothing else. but then we are left here where the client the dox the user to any relay they happen to connect to.
💬 2 replies
Thread context
Root: 0000db760a5c…
Replying to: 42514a3e3a99…
Replies (2)
cloud fodder8h ago@greenart7c3 have you thought about parsing relay AUTH events to approve/reject/remember them by relay in amber? Would be a worthy feature I think given how common this pattern is.
0000 sats
hodlbod8h agoKind-based approvals is a broken UX pattern. I don't know what better would look like, but no way is a user going to know offhand what kind 68291 is. I also don't think it's realistic for signers to render every kind correctly either. Honestly I feel like developers of signers have sort of dropped the ball on exploring better ways to reconcile UX smoothness with user safety/privacy/control.
0000 sats